Babylon Carriage House in Babylon

Babylon Carriage House in Babylon
4 / 5
49 reviews

21 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702-3501, Babylon

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Bar
Features
  • Reservations
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Full Bar
  • Private Dining
  • Parking Available
  • Wheelchair Accessible
  • Serves Alcohol
Good for
  • Large groups
  • Special occasions
  • Bar scene
  • Business meetings

Restaurant Hours

Monday

4:00 pm

Wednesday

4:00 pm

Friday

4:00 pm

Sunday

4:00 pm

Is there an elevator

Yes there is an elevator. I've used it several times. Unless its broken, its still there

Do they have dj on friday nights

Sorry I don't think so

Has anyone found a lost bag and wallet it's a pink vs small backpack and a gold wallet from last Friday please let me know

Call the restaurant. I wouldn't rely on Google posts despite how wonderful and informative as they can be.

OMG does the DJ even have a clue as to what exactly REAL 80s club music was? Or even 90s? OR wait actually ANY decent dance music? Just curious?

Hmmmm I have never had any issues with the music Here. Instead of complaining.. next time try asking them to play what YOU want to hear. Just sayin . Ps I Love the Babylon Carriage House ***** FIVE STARS !!

Do they have Djs and a dance floor

They do, not a huge space for it, they have live music too

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Babylon Carriage House
DF
Daniel Flynn
google
11.20.2024
4/5

Great Food Great Steaks

Babylon Carriage House
JS
Julia Staines
google
09.21.2018
5/5

Wonderful place! Great food and service!!

Babylon Carriage House
LF
Liru Færs
google
09.13.2018
5/5

The atmosphere is amazing, the staircase can be a bit much but there is an elevator that isn't too much of a walk if stairs are hard for you. The appetizers are amazing, I particularly liked the Thai calamari, it was the right amount of spicy and fishy, texture was as expected for calamari. The freshly baked bread was a little crispy on the outside and quite soft and warm on the inside. The staff values your needs and will gladly tailor a meal for you. I got the Penne a la Vodka, every bite was a burst of flavor, the individual pieces were the right amount of soft while being sweet too. Their dessert was two generous scoops of ice cream, and for the rather large crowd we had dining there, I wouldn't have been surprised if they skimped out, but what a delight.I would definitely go here again and recommend it to friends.

Babylon Carriage House
BC
Bea C
google
08.23.2018
5/5

Food is good... Love the decorations.

Babylon Carriage House
DS
Daniel Smith
google
08.03.2018
5/5

The meals and service were ahead of my expectations. I truly liked the environment of this place. Amazing place to take the family out for dinner.

Babylon Carriage House
PD
Phoenix D'Vyne
google
07.04.2018
5/5

Carriage House is definitely a 5 star dining experience set over 3 course meals. They have a very casual but upscale-ish dining ambiance, and the service was exceptional. The amount of time and attention that went into serving us was over the top, as well as the effort that went into our food! It is definitely a little pricey if you are coming here with a family, but worth every penny if you are looking for an upscale dining venue.

Babylon Carriage House
LG
Lauren Glowatz
google
05.23.2018
5/5

Such a cute atmosphere. I attended for a bridal shower, and loved the booth setup. Service and food was on par with what I would expect.

Babylon Carriage House
en
endless noise
google
05.12.2018
1/5

i recently went to the carriage house, sitting at the bar with my friends. to my surprise, the air conditioning vent opened and the filter came down and hit me in the back. my back was covered with dust and debris. the owner was standing right there, said nothing, didn't even come over to apologize. she only offered us a free drink. i found it extremely unprofessional that she was not apologetic for what had happened and brushed it off. this situation could have been way worse and depending on who's sitting at the bar next...it might be! be warned any bar goers for the surprises hiding above your heads.

Babylon Carriage House
NS
Neal Slattery
google
04.16.2018
4/5

Food was excellent and the service was great. The 2nd floor dining area is very comfortable.

Babylon Carriage House
SM
Star Morris
google
03.17.2018
5/5

Food was so delicious, in times like this where we cant go anywhere they make it a little better. We ordered three different meals & everything came fresh & made as we special requested. Delivery guy was quick and polite. Receptionist was kind as well. Loved the service !Star

Babylon Carriage House
Mel
google
03.07.2018
3/5

Went here on a Saturday night with reservations for a small group. We waited a bit for our table and had to sit on the stools. Even though it wasn't that busy, we waited in between drinks and courses. The waiter was ok but he could have been better. The Thai shrimp was very good and flavorful. The entrees were very good also and portions were nice. Overall decent experience but I have to say that for the amount of tables and people there the service should have been better and faster and I shouldn't have to constantly ask for more water or drinks.

Babylon Carriage House
3dmils0ng0n
google
03.07.2018
5/5

This is the best restaurant my stepdad works here and I’ve been there a lot of times and the food it’s so delicious please go here

Babylon Carriage House
RB
Roxana Borris
google
02.09.2018
5/5

Terrific food, nice relaxed atmosphere from casual cozy to party. Prix fixe menu is great value. Location perfect for before or after Argyle theater.

Babylon Carriage House
DM
Daniel M. Agababian
google
01.12.2018
4/5

Cozy place... Can get really busy at times

Babylon Carriage House
MS
M Scotto
google
11.18.2017
3/5

Went for a 60th surprise bday. We had a private room and the service and food was really good! Very friendly staff and very accommodating! However, after writing this review, I found out that there were several discrepancies. They were supposed to have more servers for the 30 guests they had for this party; they were short place settings: supposed to have 30 but only had 26. In the middle of the party they had to set more tables and dinnerware. Was supposed to be an open bar, but guests were told only Beer, wine and soda for the first hour of the party. And on top of that, an automatic 20% gratuity was added and the Maitre D' was never there. quite a disaster in hindsight.

Babylon Carriage House
JL
Jenny Lee Urban
google
11.06.2017
5/5

Thai calamari was very good. Went for birthday celebrations, had filet mignon with truffle oil macaroni. Unlimited wine on Thursdays for $12

Babylon Carriage House
TL
Tyrion Lannister
google
11.06.2017
4/5

Great service in a higher end but still casual atmosphere. The salmon dish is quite good.

Babylon Carriage House
RD
Robert Donat
google
10.08.2017
3/5

Good vibe. Food is average. The Buffet they serve at parties like I went to is the same as the Friday happy hour used to be. Nice atmosphere though. Good people as clientele. Parking is good after a certain time when the local fuzz stops hassling you. Big lot, you may have to walk a bit.

Babylon Carriage House
PB
Patrick Bruno
google
08.27.2017
5/5

Food was excellent and the service was excellent for a Tuesday night. Prices was good for 2 salad, 2 dinner a bottle of wine and dessert and cappuccino.

Babylon Carriage House
KB
Kevin Brophy
google
08.17.2017
5/5

It was my first time there. The food was EXCELLENT, The service was EXCELLENT!! I had the filet mignon. I will definitely be going back to eat there again..

Babylon Carriage House
MV
Michelle Valdina
google
07.12.2017
5/5

Great first time experience. Our server Eric was on point.

Babylon Carriage House
LD
LaVeda Davis
google
06.05.2017
5/5

Very charming. It's a beautiful place to have dinner for any special occasion. Great ambiance!!!!

Babylon Carriage House
LL
Lala Lin
google
02.27.2017
5/5

Loved the truffle mac and cheese!! Drinks are always great!! DJ on Friday and Saturday nights for a great nite out.

Babylon Carriage House
GG
Gary Gisonda
google
01.16.2017
4/5

Very good food and service. Went during restaurant week. Well worth the price.

Babylon Carriage House
LB
Lolo Benitez
google
01.05.2017
3/5

The place is good unfortunately most of the crowd are teenagers

Babylon Carriage House
GJ
Gary Joseph
google
11.17.2016
4/5

Went to the Carriage House for my birthday weekend. The wait was 40 minutes. But well worth it. I had the Center Cut Filet Mignon with Truffle Mac and Cheese and asparagus. Amazing. And my wife had the shrimp scampi. Definitely would recommend this place for a nice dinner and dancing. The restaurant has a section, called The Loft, where you can dance and drink.

Babylon Carriage House
AM
Adis Medrano
google
11.08.2016
4/5

Friendly Staff & great food @ a reasonable price!Great crowd on Friday Nights!!

Babylon Carriage House
PF
P. F.
google
10.18.2016
5/5

Came here for a Bridal Shower Brunch. Most delicious food spread ever. Nothing tasted bad. Coffee was on point. Mimosas were on point. Service was on point. HIGHLY reccomended. Beautiful atmosphere as well. Great for any occasion.

Babylon Carriage House
GG
Greg Gelsinger
google
10.14.2016
3/5

First time visit with in-laws for Thanksgiving dinner.... Services were confused.... Waited about 30 minutes for our 'pre-reserved' table.... Got shifted to a 'High Table' that my 94 year old father couldn't begin to scale the chair.... waited another 15 minutes for another table.... Food was so-so....

Babylon Carriage House
JD
Jo Duncan
google
09.26.2016
5/5

Terrific food, nice relaxed atmosphere from casual cozy to party. Prix fixe menu is great value. Location perfect for before or after Argyle theater.

Babylon Carriage House
HJ
Harikliamegas Jpz_2007
google
07.19.2016
5/5

Great service, great food, great atmosphere, and very elegant!

Babylon Carriage House
SR
Samuel Robinson
google
07.07.2016
5/5

Had a awesome experience in this spot with my wife. The food comes fast and the customer service is just great. Prices are affordable.

Babylon Carriage House
GW
Gary Westwood
google
07.02.2016
5/5

The atmosphere is awsome, the staff was excellent, and the food was outstanding!! Make reservations first for a splended dinning experience!

Babylon Carriage House
RS
Robert Sanicola
google
06.02.2016
5/5

One of my top favorite restaurants!!! The food is amazing, service is great, atmosphere is classy, fun and trendy. Lastly, the manager and owner are the best!

Babylon Carriage House
DB
Deja Blue
google
05.27.2016
4/5

Excellent place for Holidays dinners and romantic events

Babylon Carriage House
SM
Sammy Martinez
google
05.25.2016
4/5

Service was great. Courtney was fantastic. We had the restaurant week menu. I hear the stuffed salmon, shrimp and asparagus ravioli along with the chocolate cookie dessert. My friends had the steak sliders, churrasco with penne and the cheesecake. The salmon was dry and under seasoned. The sliders were mediocre. The best part of the meal was the ravioli. Delicious! Along with the cheesecake.

Babylon Carriage House
kc
kerry calabrese
google
05.04.2016
5/5

This visit was for a bridal party. Staff was very attentive. They couldn't be more helpful without being annoying. The food was a brunch buffet and very good. Good choices and plenty. Restaurant is very pretty. I would highly recommend.. I look forward to going again

Babylon Carriage House
DD
Devoras Devora
google
05.04.2016
4/5

Great food.

Babylon Carriage House
SC
Steph C
google
04.23.2016
5/5

Great atmosphere! Food was awesome especially the deep fried mac and cheese and the nutella empanada!!!!!! Love their specials, they have unlimited wine for $12 on Thursday. Awesome deal

Babylon Carriage House
JF
Joanna Florenza
google
04.20.2016
5/5

LOVE IT HERE! I attended a bridal shower here a couple days ago and had a GREAT time! The waitresses were attentive and caring! There were only two, I didn’t catch their names but one had short hair and the other was a brunette. We were in a private room and the shower was so classy and nice! Definitely will be coming back for dinner!

Babylon Carriage House
LG
Lisa G
google
04.17.2016
4/5

We were here for a bridal shower. The staff was on top of everything & the restaurant was beautiful (decorated for Valentine's day) the buffet food we had was delicious. Would love to come back for dinner.

Babylon Carriage House
pg
pascale guilliod
google
04.16.2016
5/5

Amazing dinner. Great server:Allie. She was friendly and fun. Melissa the manager paid us a visit. And price was outstanding : the two of us had two appetizers two lobster dinners three cocktails coffee and dessert. The total was $60 per person.. it was delicious. We will be back.

Babylon Carriage House
DC
Dark Chylde
google
04.13.2016
5/5

Super friendly staff, amazing food. Just wish they had more parking lol. They had more than one bridal shower going on, so I had to park halfway down town and walk.

Babylon Carriage House
GW
George Williams
google
04.12.2016
4/5

Great place and food really nice people li ice tea was awesome

Babylon Carriage House
CH
Cindy Hussey
google
04.01.2016
5/5

This is one of my favorite go to restaurants. I love the classic history and charm of this establishment. More so, service is always pleasant and professional and food quality, preparation, and timeliness is outstanding! I'm never disappointed and the range if food options on their restaurant week is always extensive. They are great for bridal showers, special events, etc.

Babylon Carriage House
TC
Tommy Cerino
google
02.27.2016
5/5

Very Nice Place to eat. Looking for a place to dance on Friday Night the DJ's Claudio and TJ are Awesome! They will keep you Moving! with their live remixes!

Babylon Carriage House
RR
Robert Russo
google
02.22.2016
5/5

Great food, excellent service, very nice atmosphere!

Babylon Carriage House
GJ
George Johnson
google
02.07.2016
1/5

Very noisy. Good food could make better drinks

Babylon Carriage House
DP
David Phaneuf
google
01.23.2016
5/5

I had a superb at this restaurant. We enjoyed the first-rate vibes and the menu. The staff members were super personal. I’m happy we eventually managed to visit here.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 16314225161

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!